
By Leslie Vasquez
For generations, the car has symbolized American freedom, promising the ability to go wherever, whenever. But in a world built for drivers, vehicle ownership has become an expensive necessity rather than a choice, leaving thousands struggling with high costs and nondrivers with limited options to get around. Recent polling indicates that Americans increasingly doubt the promise of car ownership and want better options for getting around.
A new report from the Climate and Community Institute (CCI), Cheated by Car Dependence, challenges the assumption that a car-centered transportation system serves everyone. Its findings reveal a costly contradiction: Americans depend on cars to access everyday necessities, yet many feel trapped by that dependence.
The financial burden is substantial. National polling cited in the report found that 41% of adults sometimes, often, or always have to spend less on other things to afford transportation. Among the lowest-income households, those with cars spend 40% of their income on transportation, compared with just 7% for households without cars.
The cost of car ownership can also limit who has access to a vehicle. One new study finds car ownership is “shaped not only by household preference but also by the financial constraints associated with the insurance market.” Its authors say lower-income communities pay auto insurance premiums comparable to those in wealthier areas, placing a disproportionate financial burden on residents and limiting car ownership regardless of their need for a vehicle.
As we explored in our Transportation Disrupted series, people respond to rising transportation costs by adjusting their behavior. But when driving is the only realistic option, that often means spending less on groceries and other necessities, and cutting certain trips altogether.
This problem extends beyond drivers. More than a third of Americans do not drive, including those with health issues, those who can’t afford to, and those who simply choose not to, according to CCI’s report. Its authors estimate that more than 37 million people in rural and low-density communities live in households with fewer cars than driving-age residents.
Americans’ interest in car-free or car-light living spans geographic and socioeconomic boundaries. A study by Arizona State University researchers earlier this year found that 18% of surveyed car owners wanted to live without a car, while another 40% might consider it. Those perspectives crossed income, age, racial, educational, and neighborhood groups. Yet our conventional approaches to planning and design widely prioritize drivers and car-oriented communities.
Reducing car dependence is not about taking cars away from people who need them or making driving impossible. It is about ending the assumption that everyone must own one to participate fully in society. When policymakers invest in transportation options and support development patterns that serve nondrivers, they improve affordability, access to opportunities, and freedom of choice for drivers alike.
Photo credit: Brian Miguel via Pexels. License.